Skip to main content

Shop Management

Brian von Tress Says Caring About Employees Is Collision Pros’ Secret Sauce

Von Tress on starting an MSO at 53, building accounting before scale, protecting culture, and leading through the Camp Fire.

Brian von Tress Says Caring About Employees Is Collision Pros’ Secret Sauce
Collision Pros CEO Brian von Tress on starting an MSO at 53, accounting before scale, culture at 14 locations, and the Camp Fire.

On a recent episode of The Collision Vision, host Cole Strandberg sat down with Brian von Tress, founder and CEO of Collision Pros. The company operates 14 locations across Northern California and Nevada.

Von Tress grew up around the business. His grandfather was trained as a bodyman through a government program after the Great Depression, and his father was a State Farm adjuster. Von Tress started at a nearby body shop sweeping floors and washing cars to pay for his first car. “I had no intention of this being my career,” he said. Over time, he said, “I realized that that’s just who I am and that I love it and I’m part of the industry.”

He worked as a painter, then went to college. After graduating, he struggled to find work until he paired his degree with his shop experience. “When I started putting the body shop stuff on the application with the with the college degree, all of a sudden I had interests,” he said. He took a sales job with Sherwin-Williams, moved into management, and later earned an MBA to set himself apart for a business development manager role.

On the episode, he discussed the leap that started Collision Pros, the lessons of scaling, and why he believes regional independents hold an advantage in a consolidating industry.

Caliber gave him a preview of where the industry was heading

Von Tress later joined Caliber, which he recalled had around 15-17 stores at the time. Working in Southern California, he said, showed him where the rest of the industry was heading. “I got to see what Sacramento was going to look like 10 years later or the rest of the industry,” he said.

Caliber asked him to analyze why its Los Angeles-area stores were underperforming. He told his boss the stores could succeed with better management. “I think they still have great bones,” he said. He then spent about a year and a half running those stores, commuting 50 to 60 miles each way. He said he had never worked in a shop office or written estimates before that role. “I find that the more difficult things are, the more I learn,” he said.

Long hours and a new baby prompted the family to move back home. He then joined Bodycraft, a three-store Sacramento operation founded by Bruce Mackie. The company grew to 19 locations, 14 of which he oversaw.

Key takeaway: Study markets that are ahead of yours to see what’s coming. Von Tress said what he saw in Southern California made it easier to build what came next.

Von Tress says execution, not SOPs, is the secret sauce

Von Tress said he doesn’t consider himself an innovator. “I’m more of a copier. I can see formulas and the way things are operating and just copy it,” he said. “Really, I’ve built my whole career just watching great people do great things.”

He said he has shared his standard operating procedures with other operators. When people asked why he would give away his secret sauce, he told them the procedures weren’t it. “The doing, it’s the secret sauce. That’s the hard part,” he said.

Key takeaway: Don’t guard your SOPs. Put the effort into executing them consistently, which von Tress said is the hard part and the real secret sauce.

The first stores were harder than the business plan

“I was more confident than I probably should have been,” von Tress said. “It was it was harder than I thought.”

His fast-growth plan meant opening a second store just three months after the first. “I went from one store and three months later I opened the second store and neither one of them making money,” he said.

At the second store, the DRPs initially pulled their work. “All the DRPs turned us off and we went from having some work to no work and I kept telling them trust me and they thought I was the craziest guy ever,” he said. Once insurer programs he had relationships with turned the shop on, the store had more work than it could handle.

That store was about an hour and 45 minutes from home, so he parked a trailer there and lived in it for seven or eight months. He said he worked 15- to 16-hour days, prepping cars and writing estimates. When he found a manager to take over, he removed the trailer. “I do not want to do that again,” he said.

Key takeaway: Expect a new location to be harder than the plan, and be ready to take on much of the work yourself until the right manager is in place.

Tier two markets and EOS shaped the growth plan

Von Tress said his original business plan called for three or four shops. That changed when Jason Mian, who had worked for him and stayed on with Caliber, joined him. Mian brought a stronger operations background. They drafted a new plan at a retreat on the coast, drawing on the EOS framework from the book “Traction.”

“I think our original plan was 10 stores in 10 years,” he said. He said the company reached that goal along with its earnings targets, and it still runs on EOS today.

The strategy avoided head-to-head competition with large MSOs. “The original plan was to stay away from the big markets where you’re competing with thelarge MSOs and to go into the smaller tier two markets and pick up shops that had a good reputation,” von Tress said.

Often those were shops whose owners were ready to exit. Once acquired, the plan was to “add some training, new equipment, shine the place up, add some DRPs and go.” Mian started by running one store and was later promoted to run all of them, while von Tress shifted to a corporate role.

Key takeaway: Look for well-regarded shops in smaller markets, then add training, equipment, and DRP relationships. Von Tress said that formula drove Collision Pros’ growth.

Accounting has to come before multiple stores

Asked what had to be in place before scaling, von Tress said, “Accounting is probably the biggest piece.”

He said owners have to recognize their limits. “You can be good at some things, but you can’t be great at everything,” he said, adding that leaders have to be willing to hire people who are better than they are in certain areas. For a long time, he said, the corporate team was just three people.

He said accounting is also what he wishes he had understood sooner. “To get past three or four stores, you have to have a solid accounting process,” he said. An owner can run one or two stores from experience, he said, but “once you get multiple, you have to know where the money is and run it somewhat off numbers.”

Key takeaway: Before growing past three or four stores, set up solid accounting and P&Ls you can read, and hire people who are stronger than you where you’re weaker, von Tress said.

Culture means removing even top producers who hurt the team

Von Tress said EOS keeps the company’s core values in front of the team, and the team calls itself out when it drifts.

He said the company removes employees who make work difficult for others as quickly as it can. “I don’t care if it’s the most profitable guy I got,” he said.

He said holding culture together gets harder with each location. “When you get to two, it gets even harder to be what you want. You get to three, it gets harder and harder,” he said.

Key takeaway: Protect your culture by removing employees who damage the team, even your most profitable ones.

Handwritten cards still go to every employee

Von Tress said being a great employer starts with understanding each person’s goals. “You have to care about their career and them to meet their goals,” he said. Because he is no longer in the shops daily, he said, the company has to hire and train managers to that standard.

He still sends handwritten birthday and anniversary cards, with a small gift card, to every employee. He started more than 20 years ago, and it now adds up to 400 or 500 cards a year. “In some ways the larger we’ve got the more impact it’s had,” he said.

At annual planning meetings, he asks what Collision Pros can do that large MSOs and small shops can’t. He said taking care of people is central to that answer and is easier at the company’s current size. “If we had 400 locations, I certainly couldn’t be sending out cards,” he said.

Key takeaway: Keep personal gestures as the company grows. Von Tress said his handwritten cards have had more impact as Collision Pros has gotten bigger.

The Camp Fire taught him to stay composed in a crisis

The Collision Pros location in Paradise, Calif., the company’s third, burned in the Camp Fire. Several employees lost their homes, according to the Chico News & Review. “The whole town burnt down. Like there was nothing left,” von Tress said.

He said the company’s response wasn’t a business decision. “This was more from a humanity standpoint,” he said. The company started a GoFundMe, put in its own money, and the industry contributed as well.

Von Tress moved the Paradise staff to the Chico location about 15 miles away. He also asked insurers for help. “I reached out to a number of insurance companies and I said ‘help me help these people,’ and they got on board in a big way and our shop got packed,” he said. With so many displaced residents and fire-damaged vehicles in Chico, he said, “I was the only guy with capacity because I had staff.”

He said the lesson was to think through the worst case and then make a plan. “The big thing from a leader is you can’t freak out because everybody freaks out, right?” he said. More broadly, he said, growing a business comes down to doing the right thing. “People are watching all the time,” he said.

Key takeaway: In a crisis, stay composed, think through the worst case, make a plan, and ask partners such as insurers for help.

His advice to executives eyeing entrepreneurship: do it

Asked whether he would have started sooner, von Tress said, “I might have jumped in earlier, but it wouldn’t have been the same story.” He said each role prepared him for challenges like COVID and the fire. He is a member of Coyote Vision Group, where some members are young.

His advice to executives considering their own business was direct. “I would say do it. It’s been the greatest journey of my life,” he said. Growing a company for someone else is rewarding, he said, but “there is nothing like doing it yourself.”

Key takeaway: Executives who feel the pull to build their own business should take the leap, von Tress said, since the experience they’ve gained will help them handle what comes.

Von Tress measures success by the families Collision Pros supports

Von Tress said he still enjoys the people and the acquisitions. “It’s the hunt,” he said. Some employees who started with him as detailers now run stores or serve as regional managers.

Asked what he hopes to leave behind, he pointed to jobs and careers. “There’s literally hundreds of people that are that are being fed off of what we do here at Collision Pros,” he said.

He said operators early in their growth can reach him through the Collision Pros website or by email. “I get great joy out of it,” he said of advising them.

Lisa McArdle

Lisa McArdle is the associate editor at Autobody News. A veteran writer and editor with more than 15 years of experience across newspapers, fitness, insurance,... Read More

Digital Partners