Local news stories affecting the auto body industry in Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, South Dakota, and Wisconsin
An insurance company accused of refusing to cover a customer’s collision claim is seeking to dismiss a St. Clair County, IL, lawsuit.
According to the complaint filed Sept. 17, plaintiff Paula J. Beland claims she was involved in a chain traffic collision on Sept. 17, 2011. A driver hit the car behind Beland, which then allegedly hit her car.
Beland had insurance through defendant Automobile Club Inter-Insurance Exchange at the time of the collision, the suit states. She filed a claim with the insurance company, seeking money for her damages as a result of the collision. However, the insurance company refused to settle Beland’s underinsured motorist claim, the complaint alleges.
The defendant filed its motion to dismiss on Oct. 18 through attorneys Michael Reda and Daniel C. Lytle of Hepler Broom in Edwardsville claiming the plaintiff failed to state a cause of action.
“In this case, plaintiff’s complaint fails to separate causes of action for breach of contract and recovery pursuant to the Illinois Insurance Code,” the motion states.
The defendant filed for a substitution of judge on Oct. 29, which Chief Judge John Baricivic granted. Circuit Judge Robert LeChien was previously assigned to the case. A new judge has not yet been assigned.
The plaintiff seeks a judgment of more than $35,000, costs, fees and an additional $25,000.
Beland is represented by B. Jay Dowling of the Law Offices of Sterling and Dowling in Fairview Heights.
Michigan officials and law enforcement authorities say they’re cracking down on fraudulent auto insurers and Michigan drivers who purchase their policies.
But consumer advocates say the new initiative, announced by Republican Secretary of State Ruth Johnson, fails to address the underlying problem: exorbitant car insurance premiums caused by Michigan’s mandatory no-fault system that requires drivers to purchase basic coverage that includes unlimited medical benefits. Lawmakers are expected to debate this fall on whether to reform the system and make it more affordable.
Baker’s Collision Repair Specialists Inc., a collision repair facility located in Mansfield, Ohio, will host an Open House to celebrate "60 Years in Business" on Saturday, Oct. 5 from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Baker’s has been in operation by family members since it was founded by Mervin and Esther Baker in the fall of 1953. Starting out in a two-car garage on Snyder Street in Mansfield, it has now expanded to its current 40-stall facility that has been located on 5th Avenue since 1956.
"The Baker and Powell families and all of the staff extend an invitation to the public to attend and join in the celebration," said a company spokesperson. "This day is to honor all of our generations of customers that have made it possible for us to continue to be of service to them."
Complimentary hot dogs and bratwurst, chips and soft drinks will be served to attendees. There will be facility tours, displays of community projects and door prize giveaways, including an iPad as a grand prize. In addition, Baker's has partnered with Sherwin-Williams to showcase the No. 16 Greg Biffle Stock Car at the shop.
Midwest Collision Center Inc. announced a major green initiative to replace their fluorescent lighting with LED lighting from Green Universal Solutions Co. (GUSCO) becoming the first automotive body repair center in Michigan to make the change to replace every light with LED lighting.
“Besides being responsible in going green with LED, you get so many advantages ... better and brighter light, tremendous savings in energy used, the cost of the energy, replacement and maintenance costs with some of the LED lighting having an L70 rating of 200,000 hours,” says Ed Schippers, co-owner of Midwest Collision. “It really was a no brainer, a win-win-win for our decision to go LED. We win with all the savings... computed to be over $130,000 during first 10 years based on our current energy bills. Our employees win with better, cleaner, brighter, safer LED light. Our environment wins because when we save energy, we save all the pollutants that happen from creating that electricity.”
“I also appreciate the way that Steven Kuivenhoven, energy consultant from GUSCO, approached us... in that he had a conversation, he asked questions, listened to us share how our current lighting was inadequate, he asked for copies of our energy bills, took numerous light readings throughout the shop, then his findings were submitted and a proposal was created by the engineers at GUSCO. He then shared the proposal with us. It was very complete with all data we needed to make a decision,” says Ed and continues “GUSCO even fills out the consumers energy incentive paperwork for us... how great is that?” Joe Brule, co-owner of Midwest Collision adds, “The cars themselves are equipped with more and more LEDs. LEDs are everywhere. It’s the best time to upgrade for many reasons including the uncertainty about future electric rates. Consumers Energy supports the upgrade with an incentive and because GUSCO was able to cut our energy 76% we will, according to our company accountant, be eligible for a 179D tax deduction.”
“We at Midwest are all anxious to experience the LED lighting with the scheduled installation being the first part of September. “For the sake of our environment, your employees and your pocketbook, I would encourage every auto repair facility to contact Steven at GUSCO 269-779-6005 and learn about the savings.”
The Ohio Court of Appeals has upheld class certification in a suit alleging that the arbitration clause in a Cleveland-area dealership group’s sales agreement was unconscionable and unenforceable, according to Eric Freedman writing in Automotive News.
The 2-1 ruling against Ganley Chevrolet and Ganley Automotive Stores came in a spot delivery-related dispute that began in March 2001, after Jeffrey and Stacy Felix purchased a 2000 Chevy Blazer.
Ganley has asked the appellate court for reconsideration and, if that’s unsuccessful, may seek state Supreme Court review, says dealership lawyer Steven Dever of Lakewood, Ohio.
The plaintiffs contend that Ganley told them they were approved for 0 percent financing and let them take home the Blazer. But a few days later, Ganley told them GMAC would approve only 1.9 percent financing, which they accepted. More than a month later, they were told GMAC had rejected them. The dealership then found a bank that would provide a 9.4 percent loan, but the Felixes refused to sign a new agreement at that rate, the decision said. The suit alleges “bait-and-switch tactics,” violation of the state Consumer Sales Practices Act, misrepresentation, and emotional distress. It includes individual and class-action claims and challenges the validity of the arbitration provision in the sales agreement. A lower-court judge rejected Ganley’s request for arbitration and approved class-action status on behalf of all consumers whose sales agreement with any Ganley store had the same provision. Ganley Automotive Stores has 34 franchises in northern Ohio.
The judge found the provision ambiguous and misleading and awarded $200 in damages to each of the “thousands of members” of the class. It covers customers who signed such agreements from two years before the lawsuit was filed in June 2001 until the company changed the provision in 2007, said plaintiffs’ lawyer Mark Schlachet of Cleveland Heights, Ohio.
However, only a “handful” of those customers went to arbitration, Dever said. He added: “How can you quantify the harm when people had no complaint? The analysis is fundamentally flawed.” The appeals court held that class-action status was appropriate under the consumer protection law.
Appeals Judge Mary Kilbane said the trial judge, who handled the case for 11 years, had “conducted a rigorous analysis into whether the prerequisites for class certification have been satisfied.
Alpine Glass of Minneapolis, MN, has been awarded an arbitration award against AAA Insurance Co. for $149,500.57. The award represents 100 percent of the amount sought through arbitration for short pays from the insurer. Mike Reid, president of Alpine Glass, says the company won this arbitration because the insurer was unable to prove Alpine had unfair billing practices.
“It’s sad to see glass companies failing as a result of being desperate and accepting reimbursements that are ridiculously below what is fair and reasonable,” says Reid. “Glass companies are losing out by not fighting for a fair price. We have shown time and time again that our prices are fair and reasonable.”
According to court documents, “Alpine asserts, as assignee of its customers, that it is entitled to the full amount billed for glass repair and replacement work governed by the terms of the AAA insurance policy. The claims are from July 6, 2006, through May 9, 2012.”
“AAA did not conduct a survey of the ‘area where the car is to be repaired,’” writes arbitrator David T. Magnuson in the arbitration award. “The short-pays of Alpine’s invoices was systematic and consistent, but not based upon written estimates, competitive bids or an agreement. AAA did not comply [with] the terms of the policy in processing Alpine’s claims.”
“Alpine will continue to fight against insurers who short pay our invoices and, if necessary, we will continue to file for arbitration in order to be paid what is right,” he adds.
In July 2012, Alpine won a six-figure award against Liberty Mutual for short pays. Additional wins include six other awards from Illinois Farmers, Allstate, American Family, USAA, Integrity and Guide One.
According to the arbitration award, “The dispute arose as a result of claimant Alpine Glass’s insurance policy with respondent wherein claimant pays for glass repair and replacement work, get as assignment for each individual claim, and then submits the claims to respondent AAA Insurance Co. A third-party administrator, in turn, pays pursuant to the insurance policy what they deem to be the amount charged by a majority of the repair market for glass repair and replacement claims.”
The recent award is Alpine’s eighth within the last two years; the total of the awards is now approaching $3 million. Alpine Glass has been victorious in all of its arbitration cases. A representative for AAA had not responded to request for comment at press time.
Key industry vendors featuring hands-on demonstrations showcasing the latest technology, tools, parts and more are on the schedule for the 5th Annual Automotive Service Association of Illinois (ASA-Illinois) Chicago Automotive Networking (C.A.N.) Conference which was held Friday, September 20 through Sunday, September 22, 2013 at the Crowne Plaza Chicago O’Hare in Rosemont, IL.
The 2013 exhibitor line-up included AES Wave, ATI, Automotive Seminars, Auto Vitals, Inc., BOSCH, Combined Worksite Solutions, DELPHI, DemandForce, Fox Valley Fire & Safety, Heil Insurance, Herb Kuhn Equipment Sales, IEPA, Jasper Engines, KUKUI, LKQ, Mitchell 1, NAPA Auto Parts, Quality Oil, Snap-on and WorldPac.
“We are very excited about the vendors we had joining us this year at the C.A.N. Conference,” said Dave Walter, President of ASA-Illinois. “People from all over the United States attended C.A.N., and we think this conference was be the best we’ve ever had with the vendors, instructors and classes we featured this year.”
A new element added to the 2013 C.A.N. Conference was live interviews and streaming video of vendors, instructors and attendees from the tradeshow floor. This provided conference participants with a unique opportunity to perform equipment demonstrations, share education highlights and conference experiences live from the show. The C.A.N. Conference is open to shop owners, service writers, advanced and intermediate technicians.
For additional information regarding the conference, please visit the conference website at www.asacanconference.com. Or, contact Sharon Ozimek and Deb Bullwinkel, co-executive directors of ASA-Illinois, via email at email@example.com or by phone at (877) 272-4445, (773) 919-3875 or (630) 430-3832.
Its own Cleveland-based division headquarters was the site of the last Sherwin-Williams Automotive Finishes A-Plus™ University EcoLean™ Suite of Training Course Offerings. Featuring the ‘Achieving Service Excellence’ course, training was held August 21, 2013, in Warrensville Heights, OH.
The ‘Achieving Service Excellence’ program is designed for shop owners, production managers, customer service representatives, and estimators to provide them with the skills, knowledge, and tools necessary to improve their collision center’s quality, production, and output… by focusing on the right types of customer service.
“Lean collision repair shops— and those that utilize the right methods of customer service—are able to reduce internal costs and raise their level of CSI and output quality. This two-fold result often helps them gain a competitive advantage in their respective markets,” says Steve Feltovich, Manager of Business Consulting Services for Sherwin-Williams Automotive Finishes.
The ‘Achieving Service Excellence’ course discussed the following topics:
● How to become more profitable with a customer-focused strategy
● How to establish a proven method for providing each customer with value
● How to build a strong brand based on customer service excellence
● How to improve efficiency and effectiveness of your customer service staff
● Identifying service excellence professionals in and out of your organization
● Explain driving factors behind the experiential service economy
To register online for an upcoming Cleveland A-Plus University EcoLean ‘Achieving Service Excellence’ course, go to http://www.sherwin-automotive.com/customer-programs-services/a-plus-network/calendar-of-events/.
For more information on the A-Plus Network, call 800-798-5872 or go to http://www.sherwin-automotive.com/en/Markets/Collision-Repair/A-Plus-Network.aspx.
Several car dealerships have filed an antitrust class action against four Japanese automobile parts suppliers for allegedly rigging bids for lighting equipment sold to major car companies.
Mitsuba Corp., Koito Manufacturing Co. Ltd., Ichikoh Industries Ltd. and Stanley Electric Co. are being sued in the class action of Martens Cars of Washington Inc. et al. v. Koito Manufacturing Co. Ltd. et al., which the plaintiff car dealers filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan.