Thursday, 24 September 2020 16:52

Judge Orders an End to Spontaneous Breakage Lawsuit

Written by Emmariah Holcomb, glassBYTEs.com


U.S. District Court Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers issued an order that effectively ends the civil class-action lawsuit between Subaru of America (SOA) and plaintiffs Lucia Luong and Brian Mann in California’s Northern District.

The plaintiffs alleged the auto manufacturer was responsible for “spontaneous windshield breakage.”


This order comes on the heels of a joint motion to dismiss, in which both parties met and went to two mediation meetings. The mediation resulted in new terms, to which both SOA and the plaintiffs agreed. According to the jointly filed motion, both parties agreed to end the class action lawsuit and each side would be responsible for his or her legal fees.


Luong had alleged the windshields of 2015 through 2016 Subaru Outback and Legacy vehicles “contain one or more design and/or manufacturing defects that cause the windshield to crack, chip and/or fracture.”


Luong is an owner of a 2015 Outback, which was purchased new during that year. She claimed she noticed a crack had “spontaneously appeared” from the base of the windshield, with no visible point of impact, in March 2017. According to her complaint, she was denied warranty coverage, and the replacement windshield she received suffered from the same defect.


SOA’s attorneys responded by stating the “plaintiff and her counsel have taken an individual warranty claim worth less than $1,000 and gone nuclear with it, attempting to plead a full-blown class action lawsuit, alleging that all windshields in all model year 2015 and 2016 Subaru Outback … and Legacy … vehicles are defective because they ‘crack, chip and/or fracture’ ‘for no reason at all’ ….”

Previous Page Continue reading »

Read 215 times