Monday, 19 April 2021 18:02

Tesla Alleged ‘Driverless’ Crash in Texas: What is Known So Far

Written by Simon Alvarez, Teslarati



Share This:


On April 17, a tragic crash involving a 2019 Tesla Model S claimed the lives of two people, a 59-year-old and a 69-year-old, both of whom are yet to be identified.

Considering the nature of the case and partly due to the involvement of a Tesla, the incident has been covered by both local and national media outlets. This became quite notable in social media platforms, where the crash has been linked to Autopilot. 


This guide presents what is currently known about the tragic incident, as well as some commentary and videos from EV owners who have attempted to replicate, at least to a degree, the alleged events that led up to the crash. 


What happened?


On April 17, a 2019 Model S crashed into a tree at about 11:25 p.m. in the Carlton Woods Subdivision on Hammock Dunes Place in Houston, TX. According to authorities, the Model S crashed into a tree after failing to navigate a turn at high speed near 18 Hammock Dunes Place.


The collision resulted in a fire that took the local fire department about four hours and more than 30,000 gallons of water to extinguish. Investigators found two victims from the incident, one sitting on the passenger seat and another in the back seat. 


What did witnesses say?


KPRC 2 reporter Deven Clarke spoke to one of the victims’ brother-in-law, who stated the Tesla owner and a friend simply wanted to take the car out for a spin. The brother-in-law said there were just two people in the vehicle.


He also added the Tesla owner backed out of the driveway and then may have hopped in the back seat before crashing a few hundred yards down the road. The owner was reportedly the person found in the back seat of the car. 


What have the police said?


In a statement to KHOU-11, Harris County Pct. 4 Constable Mark Herman said deputies who recovered the Tesla are certain the vehicle had no driver when it collided with the tree. He also emphasized...

...some of the authorities who responded to the incident were reconstructionists, and they were very confident there was no one driving the vehicle when it crashed. 


“They are 100% certain that no one was in the driver seat driving that vehicle at the time of impact. They are positive. And again, the height from the back seat to the front seat, that would be almost impossible, but again our investigators are trained. They handle collisions. Several of our folks are reconstructionists, but they feel very confident just with the positioning of the bodies after the impact that there was no one driving that vehicle,” Herman said.
Was Autopilot involved?


Despite the inflammatory social media posts from some media outlets, it has not been determined yet if Autopilot had been active in the Model S when it collided with the tree.


It should be noted the roads in the Carlton Woods Subdivision on Hammock Dunes Place do not seem to have visible lane lines, which is a requirement for Autopilot’s activation. Regular cruise control could be activated in such areas as per videos from Tesla owners, but Autopilot and Full Self-Driving features are generally inaccessible in a residential area, at least in their current state. 


Is the NTSB investigating the incident?


In a statement to Bloomberg, National Transportation Safety Board spokesperson Chris O’Neil confirmed the NTSB does not plan to open a new probe about the tragic incident. 


What happens when Autopilot in engaged and a driver unbuckles the seatbelt?


One suggested scenario is the driver might have activated Autopilot and jumped into the back seat. This would have been a tricky maneuver as the driver would have had to unbuckle himself, which results in Teslas engaging their alerts and eventually coming to a stop. 


We thank Teslarati for reprint permission. 


Share This:

Read 695 times